: Five reasons this Turkey coup bid failed

16:11 Jul. 16, 2016

Five reasons this Turkey coup bid failed

Turkish people are seen outside Istanbul Police Headquarters, after a group of soldiers with armored vehicle, involved in 'Parallel State/Gulenist Terrorist Organization's coup attempt. (Getty Images)

Analysis from RFE/RL's Abbas Djavadi

Turkey's military has managed to seize power directly three times since 1960 (and forced another government from power in 1997). So why did this latest coup attempt fail?

RFE/RL's Abbas Djavadi gives his assessment of events

1. Lack Of Public Support

Three previous coups were fairly well received by a public yearning for "peace and order" to be restored after periods of social strife or violence. No such public support existed this time for the coup plotters, and few people came out to cheer them on.

Read also Nearly 3,000 arrested following failed military coup in Turkey

In fact, far larger crowds answered President Recep Tayyip Erdogan's dramatic call -- made to a television news channel via a mobile-phone video link -- to come out onto the streets to show their rejection of the coup.

2. This Time (It Seems) It Wasn't The Secularists

Turkey's military has long considered itself as the guardian of the country's secular constitution. In past coups, it has seized power from civilian governments it cast as a danger to the secular order.

This time, authorities blamed not ardent secularists but a religious figure -- Fethullah Gulen, a critic of Erdogan in self-imposed exile in the United States. (He denies being behind the attempt.) The two biggest opposition parties also came out in clear support of the government, saying the bitter experience of past military coups must not be allowed to be repeated.

3. Police, Coup Plotters Were On Different Sides

On previous occasions, the police fell into line behind Turkey's new rulers after the army's takeover. Nowadays, the police are seen as closely aligned to the government. Police officers went after the group inside the military who staged the coup bid, arresting scores of suspected rebel soldiers and officers.

Read also Failed Military Coup in Turkey: How it all unfolded (updates)

4. Coup Plotters Were A Small Part Of Army

Both the government, as well as the opposition, estimated the strength of the mutineers as a maximum of 10 to 20 percent of the army. In the past, it was the military as a whole that intervened.

5. Shutting Down The Media Is Harder These Days

As on previous occasions, coup plotters took over state television and radio, taking them off the air. But news still managed to spread thanks to nonstate TV outlets, primarily CNN Turk, and social networks, mainly Twitter and WhatsApp, which provided a platform for voices of resistance.


Society17:33 Oct. 24, 2016
From the ATO zone to classroom
Society16:36 Oct. 24, 2016
Renowned Ukrainian economist and philanthropist Bohdan Hawrylyshyn dies aged 90
Society13:27 Oct. 24, 2016
Row over returning Belavia jet: experts assess situation
Society13:05 Oct. 24, 2016
Polish women stage fresh protests over planned abortion restrictions
Society13:55 Oct. 21, 2016
One more Lenin toppled in Ukraine, this time in annexed Crimea
Subscribe to receive regular email updates about Ukraine and Eastern Europe